South African Legend Criticizes Temba Bavuma and Heinrich Klaasen After Semi-Final Loss to New Zealand
South Africa faced a heartbreaking 50-run defeat in the knockout game of the Champions Trophy 2025.
Table of Contents:
Temba Bavuma’s Slow Innings and Heinrich Klaasen’s Failure Spark Controversy
David Miller’s Lone Battle as South Africa’s Knockout Struggles Continue
New Zealand put on a stellar performance in Lahore, defeating South Africa by 50 runs in the ICC Champions Trophy 2025 Semi-Final. With this victory, the Blackcaps secured yet another ICC final appearance, where they will face India on March 9 in Dubai.
For South Africa, this was yet another devastating loss in a knockout match, continuing their long-standing struggle to perform under pressure in ICC tournaments. Despite a magnificent century from David Miller, the Proteas crumbled under pressure, falling short while chasing a target of 363 runs. They ultimately managed 312/9 in 50 overs.
Temba Bavuma’s Slow Knock and Heinrich Klaasen’s Failure Spark Controversy
Temba Bavuma’s 56 runs off 71 balls in the semi-final drew heavy criticism. While he provided stability at the top, his inability to accelerate during the powerplay put immense pressure on the middle order—one of the key reasons for South Africa’s downfall. Many fans and former cricketers criticized Bavuma’s slow approach, blaming him for disrupting the momentum in a high-stakes run chase.
On the other hand, Heinrich Klaasen, one of South Africa’s most reliable batters in recent times, collapsed under pressure. After missing the tournament’s opening match due to a minor injury, he made a strong comeback against England, scoring 64 off 56 balls. However, in this crucial semi-final, Klaasen managed only 3 runs before getting out while attempting a lofted shot to long-on, dealing a major blow to South Africa’s hopes.
But to be honest Hersh, you guys were too dependable on Klaasen. The moment he went out the middle order collapsed. Atleast bavuma tried his best. And I think proteas players don’t need any retired players as a coach they have so much of talent. Its just that they crumbled
— Asim Alam (@asimalam2010) March 5, 2025
Following the loss, a fan took to X (formerly Twitter) and tagged former South African cricketer Herschelle Gibbs, stating:
“Honestly, Hersh, you guys relied too much on Klaasen. As soon as he got out, the middle order collapsed. At least Bavuma gave his best effort. Also, I think the Proteas don’t need a retired player as a coach—they have the talent, but they just crumble under pressure.”
Gibbs responded sharply:
“Klaasen? Still needs to prove himself on the big stage, my friend. Open your eyes. And which Bavuma were you watching?”
His strong criticism resonated with many fans, who believed that Klaasen’s failure in a crucial match and Bavuma’s slow innings were the key reasons behind South Africa’s downfall.
Klassen? Yet to prove himself on the big stage my friend open your eyes .. which bavuma were you watching 😂
— Herschelle Gibbs (@hershybru) March 5, 2025
David Miller’s Lone Battle While South Africa’s Knockout Woes Continue
Miller played one of the best innings of his career, smashing a century in just 67 balls to keep South Africa’s hopes alive. However, he received little to no support from other batters, as wickets kept falling at critical moments. New Zealand’s disciplined bowling attack, led by Matt Henry and Mitchell Santner, never let the Proteas settle, ensuring that there was no miraculous comeback.
With this victory, New Zealand secured another ICC final appearance, while South Africa’s history of knockout heartbreaks continued. Despite being one of the strongest teams in world cricket, the Proteas once again failed to reach their first-ever ICC tournament final. This defeat left fans frustrated and raised serious questions about the team’s ability to handle high-pressure matches.